Calculation of PnL % not correct in bot overview?

[ecrypto]

Hi Maksym,

I found a mysterious thing in the bot overview with the Value % calculation. I’m running some combo bots (real). I’ve attached a screenshot of the overview. While most calculations are correct, some % calculations are not. All bots have only one deal open. I have attached an overview of the deals (shot at the same time!) - there all calculations are correct.

I’ve marked the calculations that are questionable with a red cross. For example: For the SUI bot (line 4) the value calculations show -30.7%, but for my understanding it should show -20.47% like it is shown in the deal list correctly.

Am I missing something? Thanx!

Overview of the bots:

List of the deals:

Bug details:

• Bot URL → for example the SUI bot: 685fa78d60e0332b07f5eeb3
• [Optional] Steps to reproduce →
• Expected result →

[Amia]

Hi,

Thanks for reporting this issue! We have received it and our team will investigate the discrepancy in PnL % calculation in the bot overview. The bot URL you provided (685fa78d60e0332b07f5eeb3) is helpful. We will provide an update shortly.

[d_yo_r]

Does anything of that help you?

Unlikely numbers

How can $68.44 (3.42%) / week = Average daily of $97857.1 (4890.14%)? [image]

Bot statistics Value is uPnL

I already tried to discuss why there aren’t clear columns PnL, uPnL and Total PnL + uPnL in the bots’ table. Let’s address it with a new observation. [image] The column Value shows -$0.64. And the uPnL is [image] which sums up to almost the same value - as expected because of the small delay between the screenshots. Thus Value in the bots’ overview is indeed the uPnL of the bot and not as the tooltip claims some strange mixture of realized and unrealized: “The total realized and unreali…

Separate column for uPNL

For bots Value shows exactly the sum of uPnL and PnL of open deals. There can be both because deals can be partially closed but then of course are shown as open. Isn’t that exactly what you are searching for? Only for closed deals there can be a PnL. Wait, let me check it for Deals as well. Yes, because of varying order sizes, which are shown in column Value (“The quantity of quote asset transacted in the deal.” - the duplicate name may be a little confusing), the column Profit is sorted by $ b…

Column for total PnL + uPnL

We have the columns Total Profit (The total profit or loss accumulated by closed deals, in dollar equivalent.) and Value (The total realized and unrealized P&L of currently opened deals in $.). Please, add a column that shows the total PnL + uPnL, i.e. the current state if we would close the bot at this point. Remark: How can Value contain “the total realized P&L […] of currently opened deals”. That is how can it be realized and open at the same time?

[ecrypto]

Thank you for your thoughts, but no, that doesn’t help me.

[Amia]

Thanks for pointing this out! Even though the deals are closed now and we can’t reproduce it directly, it definitely looks like there was a bug in how the PnL % was calculated for the combo bots in the overview. We’ll investigate this issue further to make sure the calculations are accurate moving forward.